November 4, 2023
Our friends the winery aficionados invited us to join them for the Lenz pick-up party for members, so of course we said yes. Though we’d been to Lenz not that long ago—in August, with a friend who brought his dogs along—we were happy to see what their pick-up party was like. We also got to try some wines we had not tried before.
Pellegrini used to do a pick-up party with generous spreads of charcuterie and cheeses, but since they now charge $35, we stopped bothering to go. No way will we eat $35/person-worth of cheese!

When we arrived at Lenz at 5 p.m., our group was ushered into the tasting room, where tables were set with glasses—four per person—and bamboo utensils. Soon, we were served food provided by Lombardi Love Lane Market: a couple of ravioli, a small bowl of lentil soup, and bruschetta topped with caponata and chopped tomato and garlic. The food was fine, especially given that it was free!

After we tried the four wines on offer, the director of sales, Jerol Bailey, made a short speech about the harvest and the wines, and then went around from table to table offering a few additional tastes. Lenz is one of the oldest wineries on the North Fork, and they take their wines very seriously. We liked all the wines we tasted, though some more than others.

Since this was mainly a social occasion, my notes are brief.

- 2017 Estate Selection Chardonnay $22
I was a bit leery of this one, since it is a 100% oaked chardonnay, but even though the tasting notes described it as “buttery,” it was not overly so. The butterscotch flavor was balanced by some nice citrus and green apple notes.
- 2015 Old Vines Gewürztraminer $30
I remember years ago, before I started this blog, heading to Lenz to buy their gewürztraminer for Thanksgiving. Good move. Though it did not go well with the bruschetta, it would pair beautifully with roasted turkey and other savory dishes. It has a lovely floral aroma and spicy tastes. I think it would also go well with ham, since I taste a bit of cloves.

- 2018 Estate Selection Malbec $45
Malbec is often blended with other grapes—more about that in a moment—but here it stands on its own. They say “medium” body, though I find it rather light for a red. Still, it is dry, with some tannins that make me think it might improve with age. I smell olives and tobacco.
- 2017 Estate Selection Merlot $37
So here’s the thing about Long Island merlots—just about every winery has one, or more, at varying price points. I don’t think any of them can compete with North Fork Project merlots, at about $11 for a liter. However, this is an easy to drink red, with good cherry taste and aroma, and goes well with the lentil soup.
- Cabernet Sauvignon
That’s the end of the flight, but Jerol comes to our table with a couple of other reds, and so we get to try the cabernet sauvignon, which is quite delicious, with lots of red fruit and some complex tastes. I don’t know which of the three cabernet sauvignons this is, so I don’t know the price, which could be $27, $35, or $60. As we are discussing the wines, I ask him, speaking about the malbec, why they don’t do a Bordeaux blend, given that they have all the grapes. Next thing I know, I get another extra taste.
- Firefly Red Blend $22
This is their red blend, with an aroma of flowers and fruit and a light, fruity, juicy taste. Yum, and very buy-able.
Reasons to visit: VERY dog friendly; a pleasant tasting room and outside area; a well-run pick-up party for club members; all the wines are good, to varying degrees, but I particularly liked the gewürztraminer and the Firefly Red.













