September 13, 2024

It has been a beautiful week, so when our friends the winery aficionados texted us and asked if we would like to do a tasting, we quickly said yes. We were delighted to hear we’d be going to Lieb, since we hadn’t been there since February 2020, and we were curious to see if anything had changed since Russell Hearn et al bought the winery recently. Hearn has been the winemaker for Lieb since 1993, and he also had his own label, Suhru, with an intimate tasting room on Main Road. Now the two labels are combined into one location, on bucolic Oregon Road, right across the street from Oregon Road Organics.

At the moment, the tasting menu has four options. One is just for Lieb Estate wines, another for just Suhru label wines, and two others that mix and match the two. In addition, our very knowledgeable and chatty server, Nate, told us we could sub any particular wine in or out of a list. Our friend is a member of the Lieb wine club, and was entitled to two free tastings, so we deferred to him. He decided to get the Lieb Estate flight, and we decided it would be fun to follow suit, so we could compare opinions. You get five tastes for $30 (if you’re not in the wine club!).





Nate informed us that in the future they will be editing these lists, to remove redundancies, and will probably use the Suhru label for some experimentation.

After deciding on our flights, we turned our attention to the food menu, since it was lunch time. They have a well-curated list of cheeses and “accoutrements,” so we chose the 4 ounce serving of Beemster cheese, a well-aged Gouda from the Netherlands ($16), the smoked trout ($18), and Marcona almonds ($6). The food came out tastefully arranged on trays: a generous serving of cheese, plenty of crackers, a fillet of pink smoked trout, plus a scattering of dried apricots. Nate also brought us a bottle of nice cold water to share.

As we sipped and munched, we admired the beautiful setting, the warm day, and the pleasant patio where we sat and chatted. One topic was whether or not it made sense to grow pinot noir grapes on Long Island, since apparently they don’t do as well as other varietals. That means wine made here from them may be more expensive than it’s worth, which led to a discussion of the issue of price and value. I was thinking about merlot, one of the most prevalent grapes on the North Fork, local wine from which can be priced anywhere from about $11 to $75, or more. What makes one cost more than the other, and is it worth the difference?

- 2021 Sparkling Pinot Blanc $58
It always feels very festive to start with a sparkler, so we clinked glasses and sipped. Nice aroma of ripe peaches, lots of fizzy small bubbles, good fruit flavors and not sweet. One friend commented that it was “good for celebratory occasions.” Good beginning!
- 2022 Pinot Blanc $26
The aroma of this one is similar to the previous wine, but the taste is very light. I think it would be overwhelmed by any strongly flavored food.

- 2021 Cabernet Franc $35
We got into a discussion of the various types of oak used for wine barrels—American, French, Hungarian—and I found it interesting to learn that each one has different characteristics, which influences how the wine aged in it tastes. So much to learn about wine-making! In any event, this is a “smooth” easy-to-drink red, with not much tannins. Not much fruit, either.
- 2020 Merlot $30
Despite what the movie “Sideways” opined, I like merlots, and this one is a fairly typical North Forker, with cherry aroma and flavor, and some light tannins. Very nice.
- 2020 Meritage $50
“Meritage” means this is a Bordeaux blend, and it is my favorite of the day. Lots of dark plum and mixed berry flavor, some tannins. Yummy.

Extra! We decide, since there are still some munchies, and the day is so fine, to get a bottle of something else, and take home whatever we don’t finish. Nate brings us three little samples and an extra cup, so we can decide. We try the Suhru cabernet franc, the Lieb cab franc, and a syrah (which may be the Suhru shiraz, which is the same grape by a different name). The syrah is just okay—not enough depth for me. But, surprisingly, since our friend and I often have different tastes in wine, we both like the Suhru cab franc, which has a hint of green pepper at the end. We decide that the most important question when choosing a wine is, “Do I like this?” We like it.

Reasons to visit: location off the beaten track, with no limos or buses allowed; beautiful bucolic setting, with a comfy patio and pleasant tasting room; the sparking pinot blanc, the Meritage, and the Suhru cabernet franc; nice selection of cheeses and nibbles.





















































































