http://www.mainandmillhouse.com
August 5, 2024

As we drove past the corner of Main Street and Mill Lane, we noticed a fair amount of construction, plus new vineyards all along Mill, and now we know why. The owners of Rose Hill and Croteaux are expanding their wine empire with new vines and a new production facility to supply their new tasting room, which is in the 1870-era house that used to be the home of Sherwood House Winery. Though the layout of the main room is similar to what it had been, with couches flanking a fireplace and a bar along one wall, the look is very different, thanks to Lumber & Salt. If you have been to other projects of theirs, like the Terra Vite tasting room, you won’t be surprised to learn that the design features re-used architectural elements from other places.


The outside areas, both front and back, have also been redone, with attractive seating and well-placed umbrellas and sun shades. However, on this quiet Monday, it was too hot to sit outside, so we opted to sit in a comfortable corner of the tasting room. When we were done we thought about browsing the William Ris Gallery, which is adjacent to the winery, but decided we were ready to head home.


Our server, Margot, greeted us cheerfully and noted we could sit wherever we chose. She also pointed out the QR code on the table, which led us to the menu. They have two tastings, $30 each, of five wines, labeled “Main” and “Mill.” I could see that some of the wines in each were also available at Croteaux or Rose Hill, so I chose Main, which seemed to have more wines that were new to me, since we had recently been to Rose Hill, and we’ve often been to Croteaux, though not so far this summer.
They also have a rather eclectic menu of snacks, from $5 for a bag of North Fork potato chips to $90 for “Gourmet Tater Poppers & Caviar,” “crispy tots with Osetra caviar & crème fraiche.” Really? More practically, they also list several non-alcoholic drinks, including a Shirley Temple.

The tastes, a fairly generous pour, came in a round tray, with labels under each little glass explaining the wine on top of it. As we sat and sipped and chatted, Margot made sure to check on us just the right number of times, and answer any questions we had. Overall, my tasting buddy said he was “not excited” by the offerings. Nothing was bad, but also nothing made us sit up and take notice. On the other hand, they are new, so we’ll be interested to see how the wines develop over the years.

- 2023 Daisy $38
Our first wine is made from grapes from the new vineyards on Mill Lane, and was actually our favorite of the day. It is made from sauvignon blanc grapes, and is light, with tastes of citrus and peach, slightly tingly on the tongue. Surprisingly complex. It would be great with oysters.
- 2023 Palmilla $34
In June we had this wine at Rose Hill, and liked it. It is a blend of gewürztraminer, albariño, chardonnay, and pinot grigio. Though it has very little aroma, it has plenty of tropical fruit and orange tastes, and has enough interest to be served as an aperitif wine, perhaps with an array of charcuterie.

- 2022 Merlot 181 $34
The number 181 refers to the clone of merlot used in this Croteaux rosé. This is a fairly typical rosé, with a faint strawberry aroma and taste, plus some citrus. Dry.
- 2022 Rumor $38
This red, made from cabernet franc, is so light that I wondered if it had been steel fermented, but Margot informed us that it had indeed been oaked, but only briefly. It has a slight fruit aroma, perhaps of cherry, and a taste of pomegranates.
- 2021 XXI $34
No surprise, if you can read Roman numerals, the name of the wine refers to the year it was harvested. This is a Bordeaux blend, of cabernet franc, cabernet sauvignon, petit verdot, and malbec, with an aroma of mixed fruits, but not much flavor. However, it was a bit cold when served, and as it sat it got better, with dark fruit and berry tastes.

Reasons to visit: small elegant winery, with ample outside seating and a cozy vibe in the winter; it’s new; you want tater tots with caviar 😊; Daisy and Palmilla.
















































































